Delphi 2007 Handbook




Essential Pascal




social web book








November 9, 2007

Fun with Vista: 100+ Years for Copying Files

The Vista UI tries to make things easier for non-experts, but some of its flaws can drive users nuts.

A few days ago I was copying a large amount of videos (over 5GB) from two computers over a wireless network. Of course, I was expecting the operation to be slow and take many hours. After many minutes of "Calculating time...", Vista was able to figure out how much time the copy operation was going to take, but the number was a total nonsense:

43367days.jpg

Now if you think about it 43,367 days is slightly more than 118 years. And don't forget the 7 hours! If you don't have a clue, don't try to guess. People expect computers to report numbers and facts, not wild speculation. If you look at the details, in fact, I had already copied about one fifth of the data (and that was probably less than an hour in the process) and the speed, even if low, was not that bad (less than 10 hours).

Now the real problem is that the user interface is far from informative. When copying a large file, the "Items remaining" section doesn't provide a significant feedback. This is also true when copying files on the lcoal computer or to and from a USB drive. I guess it is OK to have a simple view of the progress, but when you hit "more information" you should really get it. Which file is it copying? Which is the progress within that file? Even the simplest file management freeware tools provide this level of detail. In any case, some time later (after more data was copied and with a faster "speed") the forecast would look even worse (120 years, many days, and 19 hours):

44081days

Of course, the copy operation did take a few hours only. And by the way, what it the effect of hitting cancel? Will it keep the 1 GB I've already copied of "cancel" that as well? Indeed, the animation in the window is nicer than it was on XP, but it this progress? Maybe we'll get a proper file copy dialog in Windows... in a hundred years!





 

6 Comments

Fun with Vista 100 Years for Copying Files 

 There was supposed to be an update that fixed this, 
however it's really lazy programming - I wonder how 
many people were in charge of getting this right, a 
couple of UI designers, the programmer, his section 
head and his section head's manager?

OS's should be getting faster, not bloated to fill 
the power of the current machines.
Comment by Mark Robinson [http://www.dundeemedia.com] on November 9, 11:15

Fun with Vista 100 Years for Copying Files 

Hello Marco:

"Indeed, the animation in the window is nicer than it 
was on XP ..."

Sure Microsoft has put more effort in this aspect, 
the self name of "MS Vista" is very explicit about 
Microsoft preferences with this new SO.

Regards.

Comment by Andres Fornes on November 9, 11:18

Fun with Vista 100 Years for Copying Files 

i strongly suggest everybody to use copyhandler
(http://www.copyhandler.com/)
Windows copy is very pirimitive. This tool is amazing.
Comment by on November 9, 11:21

Fun with Vista 100 Years for Copying Files 

I prefer classic file managers, like Total Commander, 
but Microsoft's way to calculate time left for 
copying is really makes me wonder if they are 
calculating it at all or using random values. And 
yes, when I click MORE INFORMATION i expect more 
information on current item, queue, progress etc. 
Comment by Sosna Andrij [] on November 9, 13:25

Fun with Vista 100 Years for Copying Files 

Had somewhat the same experience copying 1GB SD card.
This took on XP almost one hour. 
Vista said it would take 5 days and a few hours. In 
the end it took 3,5 hour to copy.
Way too looong
Comment by Roland [http://beensoft.blogspot.com] on November 9, 14:16

Fun with Vista 100 Years for Copying Files 

Let's all revolt and not buy, use or program for
Vista. I have read very little positive stuff about
this new OS and it should be shelved until MS gets it
right including the UAC that is giving all of us
programmers headaches!

My rant and .02 cents worth this morning!
Comment by John J on November 9, 17:15


Post Your Comment

Click here for posting your feedback to this blog.

There are currently 0 pending (unapproved) messages.